A lot of bureaucratic lingo was thrown around at this year’s AMS Elections debates, and it can be difficult for students who don’t work within the AMS to follow along, let alone know if they’re telling the truth.
With that in mind, The Ubyssey is fact-checking every candidate’s platform and all the statements they made during the debates to determine whether they're true, misleading or plain old false.
Here are our deep dives into some of your VP admin candidates’ more questionable claims.
Platform
Aidan Wilson: “The [room] bookings process is slow, opaque and faced certain issues this year, such as double-bookings or the inability to implement club priority bookings”
True: When the Clubhouse was operational, the AMS was aware of students reporting issues concerning room bookings and filing forms. The AMS is currently accepting room bookings through its own website.
Wilson: “Publishing an outline decision of consequential VP Admin decisions, with an explanation of why the decision was made and the expected outcomes of the decision. Such consequential decisions include: Decisions relating to expulsion and suspensions … ”
Misleading: Although it may take a while, the Operations Committee, which has decided matters of expulsion in the past, publishes its meeting minutes and agendas online. Rationales and outcomes are discussed at these meetings.
Wilson: “… Major funding projects or renovations [and] Changes of code or policy related to the Administration office.”
Misleading: The Operations Committee publishes monthly reports that outline its plans. It also publishes code changes. These reports are then submitted to Council.
Mensah: “Increasing the relevance of the Hatch on campus by launching a yearly student month and opening up space for event bookings.”
Misleading: According to the Hatch Art Gallery Facebook page, it hosts “biweekly exhibitions of student and local art.” Many recent Hatch exhibitions have displayed student art, which brings into question the purpose of a student month.
First debate
Sylvester Mensah: “IFC [Interfraternity Council] violated numerous AMS rules and were banned as an AMS Club. They’ve signed an MoU (Memorandum of Understanding) as to what their relationship would look like”
Misleading: After the AMS Council concluded that the IFC violated multiple AMS bylaws and policies, the council removed its club status to replace it with a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU). As opposed to being signed, the MoU is actually being negotiated.
Mensah: “[The Greek community] forms a huge portion of students on campus.”
False: There are 1,514 active undergraduate members of fraternities under the purview of IFC. According to IFC, UBC Fraternities’ 1,514 members make up almost half of the students in Greek Life at UBC. Assuming there are about 3,000 students in Greek Life out of UBC Vancouver’s 57,250 undergraduate and graduate students, they would form 5.2 percent of the student population. Mensah could be highlighting the idea of a community surrounding Greek Life, but it’s hard to argue 5.2 percent constitutes “a huge portion” of students.
Wilson: “Every time you book a ticket [through Showpass] 9 per cent of every ticket sale to Showpass as service fees”
Unverified: The contract with Showpass was finalized in 2018. There were talks about negotiating the contract to charge a service fee of less than seven per cent. In her 2019-20 AMS Executive Goals, VP Finance Lucia Liang too touched the idea of renegotiating the contract or finding a new ticketing service. We couldn’t verify any further developments or the current service fee for AMS–Showpass bookings.
Great Debate
Wilson: “Two years ago, there was a referendum to which authorized the sale of artwork from [Hatch’s] permanent collection”
True: While Wilson got the year wrong (the referendum was in 2017), 80 per cent of the voters said “yes” to authorize the sale of artwork from Hatch’s permanent collection in the 2017 AMS referendum.
Wilson: “[AMS food outlets] sell organic and only fair-trade coffee. We have adopted an ethical trading policy.”
True: Even though the ethical trading policy hasn’t been revised recently, according to the 2018 AMS Sustainability report, AMS Businesses sell “only organic, fair-trade coffee.”
Wilson: “Two years ago Chris kicked Franz Kurtzke from the Nest and didn’t give an explanation. And thus, that was overturned.
Partially true: On January 17, 2019, Kurtzke set up a booth outside the Nest to protest the concept of toxic masculinity and highlighted what he called “discrimination against men at UBC.” Former AMS VP Admin Chris Hakim asked Kurtzke to leave the AMS property, but he refused. Kurtzke presented his claim against the Women’s Centre at the AMS Operations Committee meeting. After the meeting, Hakim served Kurtzke with a notice banning him from the AMS property for 15 days citing “harassment and trespassing.” Kurtzke’s suspension was lifted at the second meeting because the committee ruled Hakim “did not follow proper procedure in its execution.”
Update, March 4 at 7 p.m.: This article was updated to fact-check Aidan Wilson's claims about whether Operations Committee publishes its records, and Sylvester Mensah Jr's goal to host more student art exhibitions in the Nest.
This is a live article and will be updated as further information come to light.
Share this article
